Sidle was hooked and also forged a friendship with his teachers. This past winter break, he hiked Mount Washington with a group that included McDevitt and Pesarik.
“I think Keith is a special kid,” McDevitt said. “Teachers have certain kids that are very mature for their age and students that you would trust to do just about anything. If you had met them outside of school, you would probably become friends ... I think Keith is one of those kids; he can strike up a conversation with just about anyone.”
“He's a very gifted student in the fact that he has a high level of intellect combined with high mechanical ability,” Said Pesarik. “It makes him a very good problem-solver and very good to have on any team at the school.”
McDevitt and Pesarik each mentioned Sidle's interest in fitness. It was Sidle's muscles, not to mention the dirty jeans, flannel shirt and boots, that caught the attention of MTV producers who interviewed students at Grasso last year for a reality show called, “MADE.”
He wanted to be a ballroom dancer, the beefy Sidle told them. At the time, he was hauling trash when not in school.
MTV pounced.
Crews spent six weeks following him around school and home, plus putting him in other situations like dinner with his dance partner (they probably hoped for a budding romance, Sidle says) and sending him to a salsa club.
In November, he appeared in Episode 45 of the show, taking first place in a ballroom dancing competition that he thinks was likely rigged.